Pentagon’s Hegseth moves to demote Sen. Mark Kelly and slash his pension over ‘illegal orders’ video
(January 6, 2026) In an extraordinary and highly contentious governmental action, on Monday, U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth announced that the Pentagon has initiated administrative proceedings to demote Democratic U.S. Senator Mark Kelly (Ariz.) from his retired Navy rank and to reduce his military retirement pay, citing Kelly’s participation in a controversial November 2025 video urging service members to refuse unlawfulorders. The move follows an escalating dispute between the Trump administration and Democratic lawmakers over military obedience, free speech, and accountability, according to Reuters.
Hegseth’s announcement, made in an X post and formal Pentagon communications, described the video as “seditious” and alleged that Kelly’s remarks and related statements constituted conduct detrimental to military discipline under the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). The defense secretary said he had issued a formal Letter of Censure to Kelly, which will be placed in his permanent military personnel file and initiated a retirement grade determination process that could lead to a reduction in retired rank and pension. Hegseth asserted that Kelly’s status as a retired officer receiving a military pension means he remains accountable to military justice.
~
The Video: In mid-November 2025, Kelly joined five other Democratic lawmakers—each with military or intelligence backgrounds—in a video that reminded service members and intelligence personnel of their legal obligation to refuse unlawful orders under U.S. law. In the clip, Kelly stated that “our laws are clear; you can refuse illegal orders,” emphasizing the duty to uphold the Constitution, according to Courthouse News.
You can see the actual video, posted below by Kelly and fellow lawmakers, as it appeared on social media in November 2025.
~
Donald Trump strongly backed Hegseth’s action and previously denounced the original video as “seditious behavior,” claiming without legal basis that such conduct could be “punishable by death.” Trump’s inflammatory online posts included explicit threats against the lawmakers, which drew widespread criticism from civil liberties advocates.
Pete Hegseth characterized the Don’t Guve Up the Ship video as undermining military order and discipline and insisted that Kelly’s conduct justified disciplinary proceedings under military law. He emphasized that being a sitting senator does not exempt Kelly from accountability related to his retired military status.
Mark Kelly has vehemently rejected Hegseth’s actions as politically motivated and an assault on free speech. In responses on X and in media interviews, Kelly defended his military record—highlighting his 25 years of service, 39 combat missions, and tenure as a NASA astronaut—and vowed to fight the Pentagon’s decision “with everything I’ve got.” He called the move “outrageous,” “wrong,” and aimed at intimidating other retired servicemembers who might speak out.
Kelly now has 30 days to respond to the Pentagon’s administrative action as part of the retirement grade determination proceedings, which the Pentagon has said will conclude within 45 days. Kelly’s legal team anticipates challenging the action in federal court, asserting that his speech is protected and that Hegseth’s process is unconstitutional and procedurally flawed.
According to AP News, legal experts note potential defenses including the Speech or Debate Clause for lawmakers and the limited circumstances under which retirement ranks may be legally reconsidered.
Regarding the legality of Hegseth’s moves against Kelly, Axios shared thatdefense and military law experts are sharply divided. Supporters of Hegseth’s action argue the Pentagon has discretion to reassess retired ranks under 10 U.S.C. § 1370(f) if misconduct affecting “good cause” emerges. Critics, however, contend that retirement grade determinations are meant to reflect conduct during active service, and that Kelly’s post-retirement political speech does not qualify as military misconduct.
Some legal scholars have labeled the effort “dead on arrival” if challenged in court, arguing that policy and constitutional protections—including free speech and legislative immunity—bar such punishment. ~ Axios
Following yesterday’s announcement that Trump and Hegseth have moved forward with plans to demote Kelly and cut his pension, the Senator posted the following to social media:
Brief Bio: Mark Kelly
Senator Mark Kelly is a Democratic U.S. senator currently representing Arizona. He’s a retired U.S. Navy captain, and a former NASA astronaut. Kelly served 25 years in the Navy before retiring in 2011, flying 39 combat missions and four space shuttle missions.
Married to former Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, Kelly has been an advocate on veterans’ issues, space exploration, and national security. His participation in the November 2025 video stems from concerns about military obedience and constitutional obligations amid controversial orders and military actions directed by the Trump administration.
Opinion: Ace News Today stands with Senator Mark Kelly. In his video, he recommends not obeying unlawful orders, which cannot be spun into being taken as a treasonous statement. The measures being brought against him by the Trump administration have more to do with Kelly and company mounting a public resistance against Donald Trump’s policies and have nothing to do with Kelly’s implied sedition.
For more on the controversy surrounding Kelly and the Pentagon’s legality on being able to demote the former U.S. Navy officer and cut his pension, see the video below.
~
(Additional source: CBS News)
Posted by Richard Webster, Ace News Today
Follow Richard on Facebook, Twitter & Instagram
